Double Socks: The Who, What, Where & Why

by Rebecca Rushton 1 Comment

No doubt you've heard of double socks or double-layer socks. In this article, we’ll answer:
  • Who uses double socks
  • What they are exactly
  • Where you get them from
  • Why they work

     

    There are 2 types of double sock systems

    1. Literally wearing 2 pairs of socks
    2. Socks that have two layers at certain locations within the sock (double-layer socks)
      double socks or double layer socks
      Double socks: Wearing two different socks, one over the other

       

      To understand why double socks work you need to know about interfaces

      An interface is where two surfaces meet. When wearing shoes & socks there are two interfaces (see image below): the skin-sock interface (black line) and the sock-shoe interface (blue line). Each interface has a certain level of friction. This measurement is the coefficient of friction (COF) which is a number usually less than 1. In-shoe friction levels generally range from 0.40 - 0.90 (Carlson, 2009). When blisters are a problem, there is high friction at both of the interfaces. One way to prevent blisters is to reduce the COF at one of these interfaces. Examples would be lubricants (skin-sock) and ENGO Patches (shoe-sock).

      A third interface

      But there is another way. You can create an extra interface by wearing another pair of socks, creating a sock-sock interface. If the sock-sock interface COF is lower than that of the other two interfaces, the two socks will slide across one another before there is movement elsewhere. That will reduce blister-causing shear. 

      friction interfaces within the shoe

      There are two material interfaces when wearing a single pair of socks (skin/sock and sock/shoe)

       

      Double sock research

      Wearing two pairs of socks has been shown to somewhat reduce blister incidence in a military population when compared to the standard-issue military sock (Knapik et al, 1996). The following two results are quoted from Richie (1997):

      Study 1 (1992) In a study of 357 marine recruits on Parris Island, South Carolina in 1992, the use of a CoolMax® liner with a heavily padded terry design outer sock using a wool/polypropylene blend significantly reduced blisters compared to a single layer sock (40% vs. 69%). Adding a CoolMax® liner to the standard sock significantly reduced sick call visits (24.4% standard vs. 9.4% standard with liner).

      Study 2 (1993) Another study of 1,079 soldiers in 1993 tested five sock systems on blister frequency and acceptability by soldiers. Synthetic fiber socks significantly outperformed the standard wool sock. Adding a CoolMax® liner to the wool sock significantly reduced blisters. When comparing single, extra-thick acrylic padded socks to double layer sock-systems, the double-layer system was superior owing to the shielding of the open terry loops from the skin surface and the movement interface created by the double-layer system.

      In spite of these favourable research results, there is little information available about specific successful two-sock combinations. It's likely that individuals are experimenting with their own combinations in a trial and error approach. My understanding is the ideal sock combination is a close-fitting thin hydrophobic (water-repelling) inner sock, with a thicker hydrophilic (water absorbant) or moisture-wicking outer sock that maintains its bulk in spite of moisture. This sets up a moisture-wicking function as well as serving as a third interface. Richie's outstanding discussion on fibre properties states the descending order of sock fibre hydrophillic ranking is:

      Cotton - Wool - Acrylic - CoolMax® [Polyester] - Polypropylene

       

      For what it's worth, here's a summary of three commercially available double socks I have purchased and my own experience:

      WrightSock: WrightSock make socks with two layers built in to them. Every time I put them on, the inner sock tends to fold over on itself in a couple of places, enough to think that it's going to cause a problem. But that doesn't last long and has never been an issue while I'm walking or running. My foot seems to move around too much in the beginning as the two layers easily glide over one another. But again, this doesn't last long - presumably a bit of sweat increases friction levels enough to lessen the relative movement. The ones I've used have the fibre content below.

      • Lightweight: InnerLayer (70% Polyester 30% Nylon); OuterLayer (68% Polyester 28% Nylon 4% Lycra)
      • Midweight: InnerLayer (70% Polyester 26% Nylon 4% Lycra); OuterLayer (68% Polyester 24% Nylon 8% Lycra)
        Wrightsock double socks
        WrightSocks double socks (image credit: mylifeoutdoors.com)

         

        Fortisocks (no longer in production): A one size fits all thin short tubular sock designed to be the inner sock layer. The closest alternative is the good-old ladies nylon knee-high stocking cut shorter and worn under your standard sock. 


        ArmaSkin: Also an inner sock layer, the ArmaSkin sock is different to other double sock inners I've seen. They feel very unusual because the sock sticks to you. I'm sure that's because of the silicone content - silicone has a high friction level. Their fibre content is 87% polyester 16% Spandex 5% silicone. 


        You don't pull these on like normal socks - they don't slide against the skin. You need to "roll" them on. Although I got the smallest size (Ladies 2-8) they were a bit big and the heel doesn't contour exactly right. It didn't really both me though. And the big bulky seams surprisingly didn't bother me (except the one under my heel that ordinarily wouldn't have been there if you had the right sized foot).

        I am left wondering how the silicone inner side deals with sweat. I've heard of variable levels of satisfaction from runners and bushwalkers. Ultra168 had a few readers trial them to get feedback - worth a read. As did The Bushwalking Blog here.

        Knowing what I know about interfaces, ArmaSkin socks work by creating an artificially high skin-sock friction level, so the sock grips to the skin. This is good because it will save your skin from abrasion. But you better hope the friction level between the two socks is very low (there's got to be low friction somewhere) or there will be too much gripping at all interfaces with the result being the internal rubbing we call shear that causes blisters. I have a feeling ArmaSkin sock provides this better than the others, but that's just a guess.

        Unfortunately, the manufacturers are yet to test the friction properties of the ArmaSkin sock (no sock manufacturer has to my knowledge). I’d love to know as I’m sure these have a really low friction level.

         

        Double Socks or Not Really?

        I have heard of socks being referred to as double socks but which in my opinion aren't. They consist of different materials on the inner compared to the outer side of the sock, most likely serving a moisture-wicking function as decsribed earlier. However, the layers are not separated. There's a discussion about it amongst bushwalkers at http://bushwalk.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=15&t=11323&mobile=on. The way double socks work is by having the two sock layers moving relative to each other so they must be separate layers.

        Toe-socks such as Injinji can be thought of as a form of double sock system for interdigital areas and may theoretically reduce the incidence of interdigital blisters. That is assuming the COF remains sufficiently low. This sock-sock interface is actually the same material, whereas the principal of double sock systems is to use the effect of different sock materials or construction for friction reducing properties. However, blister incidence may be reduced as a result of the increased bulk between the toes acting as cushioning to reduce pressure peaks.

         

         

        Who's wearing double socks?

        My informal conversations with blister-sufferers and athletic / adventure footwear retailers indicates it is a method used more by hikers than it is runners and other athletes. Double-socking is talked about a lot on various forums as the concept is well known. I’m not sure it is used widely though, but it’s hard to tell for sure. There are many that do double-sock and get the blister prevention results they need.

        A final thought

        Assuming a double sock system reduces friction significantly, it does so all over the foot. This global approach to friction management is not without its potential problems. My own thought is, assuming vigorous or long-lasting exercise, this effect will soon be over-ridden due to perspiration such that higher friction exists at this interface. At that point, whether the friction level remains low enough to maintain blister-free low-friction conditions will depend on the individual. If you continue to get blisters, an additional strategy will be required.





        Rebecca Rushton
        Rebecca Rushton

        Author

        Podiatrist, blister prone ex-hockey player, foot blister thought-leaderauthor and educator. Can’t cook. Loves test cricket.


        1 Response

        Cj
        Cj

        June 13, 2019

        Thank you for your review of double socking. Your clear comments go beyond runner interests. I am active with gym workouts and weights. I sustained an injury in one leg that causes edema and blisters in one foot. Your article gave me another option to consider. Many thanks!

        Leave a comment


        Also in Blister Blog

        taking blister action sooner rather than later
        Sooner Rather Than Later: Lesson #6 From Adelaide 2019

        by Rebecca Rushton 2 Comments

        At the risk of sounding repetitive, it’s much smarter to take action on blisters sooner rather than later - before they're in a bad state. Here's why and an example of the difference it can make.

        View full article →

        posterior heel edge blisters from orthotics
        When Orthotics Cause Posterior Heel Edge Blisters [And What To Do About It]: Lesson #5 From Adelaide 2019

        by Rebecca Rushton

        Foot orthotics can cause posterior heel edge blisters when they sit ever so slightly out-of-place in the shoe. Find out the easy fix to this problem (you'll need some double-sided tape).

        View full article →

        Using an Engo patch to prevent and treat pinch blisters when wearing toe-socks
        A Solution To Pinch Blisters With Toe-Socks: Lesson #4 From Adelaide 2019

        by Rebecca Rushton 1 Comment

        This article explains a handy alternative to relieving pinch blisters when wearing toe-socks and when space in the shoe's toe-box is limited.

        View full article →